Fanat23

Птолемеи. Атрибуция

В теме 4 сообщения

Добрый день. Коллеги, помогите, пожалуйста, с атрибуцией данной монеты. Диаметр - 19 мм. Предположительно Птолемей Второй. 

dsc_0726.jpg.d091148187a6f1d4a5c2fb8efac4aba8 — копия (1).jpg

0

Поделиться сообщением


Ссылка на сообщение
Поделиться на другие сайты

Вторая монета для атрибуции, предположительно Птолемей Восьмой или Птолемей Шестой 

dsc_0726.jpg.d091148187a6f1d4a5c2fb8efac4aba8 — копия (2).jpg

0

Поделиться сообщением


Ссылка на сообщение
Поделиться на другие сайты

Если есть желание, попробуйте вникнуть: http://ptolemybronze.com/ptolemy_series.html

0

Поделиться сообщением


Ссылка на сообщение
Поделиться на другие сайты

 

Ptolemy VI Lotus Blossom Series
This denomination series consists of eight coin sizes with single eagle reverse and lotus blossom to the left of the eagle. Specimens are marked with EYL or no control letters in the eagle's legs. Two medium size types have a sceptre or kerykeion through the eagle. We adopt the attribution of Svoronos 1403 (with no leg controls) as Ptolemy VI due to the style of the eagle rendering and its resemblance to the others here with long tufted feathers all the way down the eagle's legs. Weiser had placed this large coin at Ptolemy III but the style of both the Zeus facial rendering and eagle feathering argue against that. We also remove some Svoronos 1404 (also with no leg controls) to an earlier series (see above) that includes Svoronos 841, 842, and 843 based on the same stylistic considerations. Only careful visual inspection can distinguish Sv 1404 that are 2nd C. coins from the types we now associate with Ptolemy III. Sv 1405 does not exist; Svoronos erred creating that catalog entry for a single coin that is actually a specimen of Sv 1636. Some EYL types display a Seleukid anchor countermark and the apparent defacement of the name Ptolemaioy from the reverse. Others show only the defacement of the inscription with no countermark, and yet others appear to be the original intact design. Others have a PTO countermark, sometimes in addition to the anchor countermark. It is thought the defaced and/or anchor-countermarked examples are coins either captured by Antiochos IV during his invasion or made from captured dies and countermarked for circulation in the Seleukid empire. We show here some examples (e.g. Sv1401) with both the full inscription and obliterated PTOLEMAI version. That invasion occurred during the middle reign of Ptolemy VI, who was for a time a captive of Antiochos IV. Upon Antiochos IV departure it is thought he created his 'Egyptianized' series of bronzes that closely mirror these in sizes and style (see further below), but which were issued at Antioch as a celebration of his, at least temporary (until expelled by Roman allies of the Ptolemies) victory over Egypt. There is one additional enigmatic coin, Svoronos 1399, of comparable style but which lacks both the lotus blossom and control marks. We do not place it here because it has no lotus flower symbol.
gae086_o
gae086_r
45mm - 91.2gm
Sv1395 - EYL
Sv1403 - nm
gae086_o
gae086_r
38mm - 45.6gm
Sv1404 - nm
gaf083_o
gaef083_r
30mm - 22.8gm
Sv1396 - EYL
Sv1406 - nm
gae195_o
gae195_r
24mm - 14.7gm
Sv1397 - EYL
Sv1398 - EYL + cmk
Some with PTOLEMAI obliterated as shown here.
gae743_o
gae743_r
22mm - 11.4gm
Sv1401 - EYL (some w/cmk)
gae462_o
gae462_r
22mm - 11.4gm
Sv1401 - EYL (some w/cmk, PTOLEMAI obliterated)
gae738_ob
gae738_rb
20mm - 7.1gm
Sv1402 - EYL
Sv1407 - nm
gae757_o
gae757_r
14mm - 2.9gm
Sv1408 - nm
gaf032_o
gaf032_r
14mm-16mm - 2.1gm
Sv1408 (Sv 1639?) - nm
0

Поделиться сообщением


Ссылка на сообщение
Поделиться на другие сайты

Для публикации сообщений создайте учётную запись или авторизуйтесь

Вы должны быть пользователем, чтобы оставить комментарий

Создать учетную запись

Зарегистрируйте новую учётную запись в нашем сообществе. Это очень просто!


Регистрация нового пользователя

Войти

Уже есть аккаунт? Войти в систему.


Войти

  • Последние посетители   0 пользователей онлайн

    Ни одного зарегистрированного пользователя не просматривает данную страницу